Skip to: categories | main content

In Defense of Mums----And the Gardeners Who Love Them


Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

Pam/Digging said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 09:04 (Link) (Reply)

At last, a hearty defense of mums. I like them too, Colleen. I think they look great with the brightly colored leaves of autumn, and they pop against purple salvia leucantha and asters here in Austin. I'll be getting a pot or two myself soon.
Colleen said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 09:21 (Link) (Reply)

Mum fans unite! :-) I am with you...I love the way mums look, especially surrounded by the reds, oranges, and yellows of the season. Great point about purple salvia, as well. I have some in my back garden, and they just "pop" against the mums.

Thanks for stopping by!
Wren said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 12:31 (Link) (Reply)

I'm not a big fan of mums myself, but I'm glad other people like them. I certainly wouldn't want every garden in the neighborhood to look exactly like mine.
Colleen said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 20:30 (Link) (Reply)

To each her own, Wren---Just don't start ripping on my mums, and we'll be fine ;-)
jodi said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 13:41 (Link) (Reply)

I'm with you also on mums, Colleen! There are certain colours I don't care for but the breeders have been hard at work creating interesting new shades that I DO need to have in my autumn garden; the bronzes, wines, pinky-oranges (I dunno what to call it) and jubilant purples are just so striking, especially put near a deep Blackie ipomea vine, or a lemon-lime licorice plant, or Persian Shield, or bronze Carex....or other interesting foliage colours. And I, who normally am a pretty free-style gardener, also like the tidy compact shape of mums, which is quite curious given my normal nature. They're just a happy blast of colour for this season. :-)
Colleen said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 20:31 (Link) (Reply)

Jodi----glad to hear it! I completely agree with you on all of the different colors available---the wine-colored ones are especially eyecatching to me. And, as you said, they look so great with so many other plants!
Carol said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 18:18 (Link) (Reply)

I always say I'm not going to buy mums in the fall, then I see them and I can't resist. I favor the purple and lilac colored ones. In fact, I have a big pot of mums sitting outside now. Plus, I have a few mums that have come back every year for the last 4 or 5 years in my FRONT flower bed, where everyone can see them.

My name is Carol and I am not ashamed to like mums in the fall!
Colleen said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 20:35 (Link) (Reply)

Ah, lucky you. I've only managed to have one mum come back for me, and this is its first year back----we'll see if it holds on for another year :-)

I like the purples, too. I read on someone else's blog (sorry, can't remember who...I'll look it up later and post the link) that purple was actually considered to be "the color of fall" for a long time. It's fairly new that people are buying red, orange, and yellow blooms for the fall garden. The things you learn reading garden blogs!

Thanks for stopping by!
OldRoses said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 19:13 (Link) (Reply)

I'm a hypocrite. I've ranted and raved for years against mums. And then when my Master Gardener graduation was finally held two weeks ago, (some people take a long time to accumulate their necessary volunteer hours) we were given mums along with certificates and other stuff. My mums are sitting proudly on my front steps.

I'm so ashamed!
Colleen said,

Tuesday, October 2. 2007 at 20:38 (Link) (Reply)

Oh, don't be ashamed! Embrace the mums...come to the dark side (oops, geeky Star Wars reference...time to stop blogging now :-) )

Congrats on completing your volunteer hours, by the way! That's awesome! I know it will take me forever to finish mine.
Fran Sorin said,

Wednesday, October 3. 2007 at 19:26 (Link) (Reply)

Colleen-

I'm actually thrilled that you had such a strong reaction to my post on mums. I particularly love the way you described their last 'hurrah' before the Michigan winter hits. And I fully appreciate your point view.

Since I wrote the post a few days ago, I have really tried to focus in on why I find them so disturbing in my neighborhood. I've decided that when I have the opportunity that I will take pictures of homes decorated with mums and see what everyone thinks of them....which ones are appealing and which ones are not.

Thanks for taking time to browse our blog and to respond to my post with such zest and vigor. Our crew over at GardeningGoneWild are all novice bloggers and I know I speak for at least a few of us when I say that we are looking forward not only to sharing and expressing our own thoughts but to participate in real discourses with other gardeners from all over the world.
Colleen said,

Thursday, October 4. 2007 at 08:25 (Link) (Reply)

Fran,

I'll look forward to seeing the photos! I can't even express how much I've been enjoying Gardening Gone Wild. Not only do I learn something with nearly every post, but the crew over there is opinionated and lively as well. I don't doubt that GGW will elicit plenty of lively responses in the years to come :-)
Kim said,

Wednesday, October 3. 2007 at 20:08 (Link) (Reply)

Finally--something on which we disagree! grin

That said, I admit that I have gotten some joy out of mums this year... from the "pages" of each garden blogger that has shared his or her enthusiasm about them. :-)
Colleen said,

Thursday, October 4. 2007 at 08:28 (Link) (Reply)

Oh, it's okay. I still like you anyway ;-)

That's one of the things I love about blogging---I get a new appreciation for plants by seeing them through other gardeners' eyes. I may not always want them in my garden, but I can enjoy them from the response they receive from others.
eliz said,

Wednesday, October 3. 2007 at 21:23 (Link) (Reply)

Nope. Can't do it! For me that is. I do appreciate them at the magnificent mum show at our Botanical Gardens, which they've been having for about 100 years.

I will be posting on it. Maybe I'll take images during the gala they have to open it, so as to include intoxicated matter, which some complain I don't have enough of.
Colleen said,

Thursday, October 4. 2007 at 08:29 (Link) (Reply)

"Intoxicating" is definitely one way to describe them, especially en masse. I'll look forward to your post!
Curtis said,

Thursday, October 4. 2007 at 10:34 (Link) (Reply)

What garden would be complete with out these showstoppers. They are great and play well next to Pansies.
Fran Sorin said,

Thursday, October 4. 2007 at 22:10 (Link) (Reply)

As promised, I walked around my neighborhood and took photos of three gardens with chrysanthemums and am now asking you to decide which photos you like and dislike. Whenever you have a chance stop by...I still can't say that I love them but when used in a way that's pleasing to the eye, I see the value to them.
Robin (Bumblebee) said,

Saturday, October 6. 2007 at 07:43 (Link) (Reply)

I have to admit that I don't really like mums much in the landscaping, although I do like very large mums in lovely containers. In fact, I have two really huge ones on my back patio that are in glorious bloom.

I think the really sad thing is that garden centers only concentrate on this one flower and don't offer much else to gardeners who want some color in the fall. Those of us who start from seed and garden all along have a lot more options. But not everyone can or wants to do that.

--Robin (Bumblebee)
Mr. McGregor's Daughter said,

Sunday, October 7. 2007 at 16:31 (Link) (Reply)

I just can't work up any enthusiasm for mums. Even the name does nothing for me. I will admit, however, that I have 1, alive & well & very perennial. I might have to devote a post to it & my ambivalence.

Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA


Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.